Tarnished Checklist Premium

Analysis by Appcrazy

I approached Tarnished Checklist Premium as a practical companion for players who want to keep track of an Elden Ring journey without relying on memory, loose notes, or a growing collection of browser tabs. Developed by LOCW, this paid entertainment app focuses on organizing quests, bosses, progress, and related checklist work. That narrow purpose is its biggest strength: it is not trying to replace the game, explain every mechanic, or become a general gaming community. It is meant to sit beside your playthrough and help you remember what you have done.

After using it as a progress companion, my impression is positive but specific. The app makes the most sense for a player who enjoys exploring thoroughly and wants a clearer record of unfinished tasks. It is less appealing if you prefer a completely blind run, dislike checking off objectives, or already have a note-taking system that feels effortless. The real question is not whether a checklist can be useful, but whether you want your Elden Ring exploration to feel more organized than mysterious.

How the checklist fits into an Elden Ring playthrough

The Lands Between can create a particular kind of confusion: you may remember meeting someone, opening a location, or hearing about a task, but not remember what should happen next. A dedicated checklist gives those memories somewhere to go. Instead of keeping a vague thought such as “I should return to that character later,” I can mark progress in a more deliberate way and decide what deserves attention during the next session.

That makes the app especially useful for long, interrupted playthroughs. If I play for a short time after work and then return several days later, a written progress trail is more dependable than trying to reconstruct the previous session. The same applies when switching between characters or taking a break from the game. A checklist cannot make every quest obvious, but it can reduce the mental effort involved in remembering where I left off.

The app is also well suited to completion-minded players. Elden Ring rewards curiosity, but its scale makes it easy to overlook optional encounters, bosses, and side content. A structured companion lets me turn a broad ambition—such as “see more of the world”—into smaller actions. I can use it before a session to choose a target, during a session to record completed work, and afterward to identify unfinished threads rather than wandering without a plan.

There is a trade-off, though. The more closely I follow a checklist, the more the game can feel like a sequence of obligations. Some players enjoy that clarity; others find that it weakens the surprise that makes exploration special. I would not open the app for every few minutes of a first blind playthrough. I would use it after reaching a point where I had already experienced the game naturally and wanted to make a second pass more complete.

Advertisements

What I found useful in everyday play

A realistic use case is a weekend session after several scattered evenings of play. I might remember that I was exploring one region, but not which nearby boss remained or whether I had already completed a related objective. Before launching the game, I can review the checklist and choose one manageable group of tasks. That small preparation changes the session from aimless backtracking into a focused route.

Another useful workflow is to treat the app as a memory aid rather than a walkthrough. I can check an item only after I personally complete it, leaving the discovery process intact. If I become stuck, I can consult the relevant entry only when I am ready for help. This approach gives the checklist two roles: a private journal for progress and an emergency reference when my own notes are no longer enough.

Take a Look at Our Blog

I also see value for players who share a console or play at different times. A visible record can make it easier to understand what has already been handled, although the usefulness depends on everyone updating it consistently. If one person marks tasks casually and another treats the list as a precise record, confusion can return. The app helps most when the user adopts a simple rule, such as checking items immediately after finishing them and leaving uncertain tasks untouched.

Trust starts with what the app actually promises

Because this is a focused companion rather than a social platform, I judge it mainly by how clearly it supports the task it presents. Its store summary describes tracking for quests, bosses, progress, and more, while the short description identifies it as a premium checklist. That creates a fairly clear expectation: I am paying for an organized Elden Ring reference, not for a live service or an account-based gaming network.

The developer is LOCW, and the app sits in the entertainment category. Its current version is 1.0.2, so I would approach it as a relatively compact tool rather than an enormous, mature platform with years of visible evolution. That is not automatically a problem. In fact, a small scope can be reassuring when the app’s purpose is straightforward. Still, I would keep my expectations centered on checklist utility instead of expecting the depth of a large community-maintained guide.

The public reception is encouraging: it carries a 4.7 average from around eighty-five ratings, with a couple dozen written reviews, and has passed a thousand installs. Those figures suggest that early users generally like the experience, but they do not turn the app into a guarantee for every play style. A checklist can be well received and still feel too structured for someone who wants complete discovery without external assistance.

The app costs $2.99, which places it in the range of a small one-time entertainment purchase rather than an ongoing commitment. For me, the price is easiest to justify when I expect to spend many more hours with the game or plan another character. If I only want a quick hint for one troublesome objective, a broader free guide may be the better financial choice. The premium model makes more sense when the organization itself is what I value.

Permissions, data choices, and sensible caution

When I evaluate a companion app, I do not want to assume that a simple interface automatically means simple data practices. The responsible approach is to look at the permissions and privacy information shown on the platform before installing, then decide whether the requested access matches the app’s purpose. For a checklist, I would pay particular attention to whether it asks for anything unrelated to recording or displaying progress.

I also recommend checking whether the app offers account controls, backup choices, or a way to remove stored information before investing heavily in a long-term record. These details matter because a checklist becomes more valuable as it accumulates personal progress. If that progress is difficult to move, recover, or delete, convenience can turn into dependence. I would not enter personal information merely because an entertainment utility presents a sign-in screen; I would first consider whether an account is necessary for the way I intend to use it.

There is a practical privacy habit I would follow with any app in this category: grant only the access that is clearly needed, review the platform’s permission prompts carefully, and revisit those choices if the app changes. I would also avoid treating the checklist as a place for sensitive personal notes. Its job is to track a game, so keeping the record limited to game progress reduces the consequences of any future account or device problem.

These precautions are not accusations against LOCW or against this particular app. They are simply good user control. The available product description establishes the app’s purpose, but a careful buyer should still inspect the permission screen and the developer’s current privacy information at the moment of installation. That is where the most relevant choices are presented to the person using the device.

Where user agency matters most

The best way to use a checklist is to decide how much influence it should have over the playthrough. I prefer a three-stage method. First, I explore without consulting it. Second, I use it to record what I completed. Third, I open it only when I want to plan a return visit or resolve uncertainty. This keeps the app from becoming a constant instruction panel while still giving me the organizational benefit I paid for.

A second method is to divide tasks by confidence. Items I have personally completed can be marked immediately. Items I suspect I completed but cannot remember should remain unmarked until I verify them in the game. That small distinction prevents the most common checklist failure: turning guesses into false progress. It also makes the app more trustworthy as a personal record, because the marks represent actions rather than assumptions.

I would also avoid trying to clear every visible objective in one session. A better rhythm is to choose a small cluster that fits the time available, then stop when the session remains enjoyable. This is particularly helpful for players who feel pressure from long completion lists. The checklist should reduce decision fatigue, not create a new form of it.

For a second character, the same tool may need a different discipline. If the app stores one general progress record rather than separate character records, I would be careful not to mark an objective as complete for everyone when it applies only to one save. In that situation, a simple note beside the task—or a separate personal convention—could prevent confusion. I would verify how the app handles multiple playthroughs before making it the only record of progress.

Strengths that are easy to overlook

One of the less obvious benefits is session recovery. Most players think of a checklist as a completion tool, but its everyday value may be the ability to restart a game after a gap without spending the first part of the evening reconstructing old decisions. That is a different benefit from a walkthrough. It supports continuity rather than simply revealing answers.

Another useful insight is that marking progress can expose inefficient habits. If I repeatedly return to the same area because I never record what I checked, the pattern becomes visible. The app can then support a better route: review the remaining objectives before traveling, group nearby work, and leave distant tasks for another session. The checklist does not plan the route for me, but it gives me enough structure to plan more intelligently.

A third trade-off concerns spoilers. Any organized list can reveal that a boss, quest, or objective exists before I encounter it naturally. Even a neutral checkbox may change how I interpret an area. I would therefore avoid browsing the entire checklist at the start of a blind run. Using only the section connected to my current progress is a practical compromise between preserving discovery and avoiding unnecessary repetition.

The app may also suit viewers or friends who want to discuss progress without relying on memory, but I would be cautious about using a checklist as a substitute for conversation. A marked item tells me that something was recorded; it does not necessarily capture why a decision was made or what I want to explore next. For personal organization, that is fine. For collaborative planning, I would still keep communication clear outside the app.

Who should choose it, and who should skip it

I would recommend this app to an Elden Ring player who enjoys completion, frequently pauses a playthrough, or wants a dedicated alternative to handwritten notes. It is also a sensible fit for someone beginning a cleanup run after finishing the main path. In those situations, the focused design is more useful than a general notes app because the purpose is already tied to the game’s objectives.

I would be more hesitant to recommend it to a first-time player who wants to discover everything without outside structure. I would also skip it if I already had a reliable system that was faster to update. A plain note, spreadsheet, or general guide can be more flexible, especially for tracking custom goals, character builds, item experiments, or personal observations that do not fit a fixed checklist.

Players who expect a full interactive wiki should also set their expectations carefully. The app is presented as a companion for tracking, not as a replacement for every form of Elden Ring research. If I need detailed explanations, extensive strategy discussion, or a broad community archive, a larger reference source may serve me better. The dedicated app wins when the central need is progress management.

The age rating is Everyone, which makes the listed audience broad from a platform perspective. That rating does not decide whether the tool suits an individual player’s habits, however. The more important personal question is whether checklists make gaming more relaxing or more procedural. I would test that by using it for a few sessions and noticing whether I feel less lost—or simply more pressured to clear boxes.

My cautious verdict after living with the format

Tarnished Checklist Premium is a focused companion whose value comes from reducing memory work around a very large game. I like the idea of keeping quests, bosses, and broader progress in one purpose-built place, particularly for long-running or completion-focused playthroughs. The paid price is reasonable for someone who will use that structure repeatedly, and the strong early rating indicates that the basic concept is connecting with its audience.

My recommendation is conditional rather than universal. Buy it if you want a dedicated progress record and are willing to manage your own spoiler boundaries, update habits, and privacy choices. Before installing, inspect the permissions, account options, and privacy controls shown on your device, especially if you plan to build a detailed long-term record. Those checks are part of deciding whether the convenience is worth it.

I would not use it as the director of my first blind adventure. I would use it as a quiet assistant: open it before a session, choose a realistic objective, record only what I know I completed, and close it when exploration feels more enjoyable without guidance. Used that way, it adds order without taking complete control. For the right Elden Ring player, that balance is exactly what makes this small entertainment app worth considering.